permalink for this thread : http://search.catflaporama.com/post/browse/531225681
Cobain_94 Posted on 9/9 18:30
5 in midfield, can it work all the time?

We seem to do well with it against the big guns then revert back to 4-4-2 for the so called "lesser" teams and it goes pear shaped. I don't see why playing it all the time would be a problem, not every team will have as much of the ball as Aresenal did today and with men breaking from midfield it doesn't have to be a negative formation.

Mattyk50 Posted on 9/9 18:31
re: 5 in midfield, can it work all the time?

who was the match against where we played 4-5-1 at home last season (or maybe the season before) and everyone on here was absolutely funing

Cobain_94 Posted on 9/9 18:37
re: 5 in midfield, can it work all the time?

Probably Pompey but can't be sure, might have been because of having Doriva, Boateng and Mendieta or an out of form Rochemback in the centre of midfield?

br14 Posted on 9/9 18:38
re: 5 in midfield, can it work all the time?

I dont think we need to be so rigid.

I think we could start most games with 5 and move to 4 at some point in the game.

On the other hand, if Woodgate had been at the back against Pompey, would the game have been the same. I dont think so, and maybe if the defence is solid 4-4-2 would be better.

Looking at the Portsmouth game again on telly it looks as though Riggott took a knock - would he have come off maybe if we hadnt been negotiating with Huth and Woodgate?

scottyc Posted on 9/9 18:49
re: 5 in midfield, can it work all the time?

nope!
next!